Love the Beef and black beer pie. When I asked for a pie to be sent up to an old mate of ours (originally from Salford) who was terminally ill, these guys pulled out all the stops at no charge - and even threw in a pork pie! He was over the moon đ„Č. Thank you so much.
First time I have tried one of these pies. it was a 750g size. (but I am a long time pie eater, i am surprise i hadn't tried before). I have read some of the other reviews and don't understand how these pies could be rated at less than 4 or 5 stars. Very good pastry and well made chunky fillings. The quality and texture of fillings and pastry is top notch. I am looking forward to trying some other flavours in the range.
A very excellent pie! Purchased from countdown greenlane. Really felt like an easy dinner and decided in a pie for myself and wife. Spent some time looking at all the options at this supermarket. Certainly wasnât the most expensive, and the cheaper ones looked average. Chose the Who Ate All The Pies âEnglish beef and black beerâ. Exceptional pie! Very impressed. Very good consistency, and NONE of the usual grisselly bits you get with other brands. It says what it is on the box. Excellent pie. Will certainly purchase again. And my wife who is no generally a fan of pies loved it.
Just tried the family steak and cheese pie - WOW!! Now that's a pie!! So tasty, rich depth of flavour and proper meat that's nice and tender. One of the best pies I've eaten and the rest of the family agree. Will definitely purchase again!!
An absolutely magnificent tasting pie (steak, mushroom & red wine) with a fabulous crispy pastry. Well done & thank you guys we will be back for more
Bought a pie for dinner tonight & when I opened it to heat in the oven it was all burnt.
Just tried the chicken and the beef pies . Delicious, best pies ever eaten.
Literally the best pie ever! Bought the Steak and Cheese 750g. Was beautiful pastry, meat was tender and plenty of it. Pastry was spot on. Had never heard of Who Ate All The Pies as a brand before but glad I found them! Happy as!
Just stopped here in our camper van to grab a bite to eat, and although the store doesnât quite have a public storefront with ready to eat pies, the owner happily offered us a couple of microwave heated pies at a discount rate and threw in a couple of extras we just âhad to tryâ for free. He told us lots about the way their pies were made and the difference between them and commercial pies and it was very enlightening! He even offered suggestions of other great pie makers along the rest of our journey through NZ - a thoroughly humble and generous man. Love this place!
Best pies I've ever had. A variety of flavours are available and service is efficient and friendly. Parking is a bit difficult to find in this one way and narrow street, but worth the effort. The special of three family pies for $40 is definitely worth thinking about too.
love, love, love Who Ate All The Pies.....have been eating them now for several years ,& they are always delicious!! my favourite is Beef, Mushroom & Red Wine. really full of beautifully cooked meat & full of flavour ! Thanks guys.....
wow, loved your pie, i got the English beef, great to find a steak pie without bloody cheese in it, do you only make family pies
Bought from new world silverstream. (Wgtn. Nz) Reheated from fresh - lamb thyme and rosemary.
Totally recommend the product- 40 mins to bake / reheat and feeds 3 easily (with some peas potatoes of course)
At $17 it's not the cheapest pre made baked pie you'll find, but I challenge you to find a better one.
Delicious !
I love these pies, yet to visit bakery, can vouche for the family pies from your local supermarket
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes