Best Extra Cheese Pepperoni in Queenstown

2 restaurant menus in New Zealand, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Sal's Authentic New York Pizza - Frankton
Sal's Authentic New York Pizza - Frankton
89/100 (220 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
American
Pizza
Italian
Italian
American
Fast Food
Fast food
Dinner
Lunch
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Pizza
Garlic Knots
mozzarella sticks
Buffalo Wings
Pepperoni Wheel
Extra Cheese Pepperoni
Fast food
Fast food
Pizza
Italian
American
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Amazing pizza! Service was fast and everything was fresh and hot. Pizza was the perfect thinness but still very airy, cheese was nice and gooey. The..."
Annik Altheman
"Pizza absolutely sensational and the cheese so melty! The staff were super lovely to us and really made our evening by being super kind 🥺🙏🏼..."
Alex
"Regular Sal’s outlet with great pizzas. Had no issues & didn’t wait..."
Ashok Sivaraja
"I'm from New York City. As a true born and raised New Yorker, I can tell you that this pizza is the closest you'll find to the real thing in NZ, and..."
Renae C. Greenman
"Sausage was sliced super thin but still an amazing pizza. Didn't have a meatball choice but wasn't..."
Be Kemp (Intheeyesofhospo)
"Luke made us a real mean pizza. Got it out in good time and it looked like a work of..."
Brig Murdock
"Great big thin crust pizza without the greasiness of a NY style pizza! We visited when only one guy was on staff. He was super at juggling the taking..."
Rufina Semovskih
"Honestly they have really nice pizzas! Very yummy and New York style indeed!! Their dough and toppings are perfect and their hospitality is amazing...."
Abdul A
"Delicious pizzas that are humongous! Tried the Buffalo, was..."
Kaifur Rashed
"We had a pepperoni and it wasn't bad. Wasn't great either. Okay experience..."
DrRadsk
"Ordered the Little Neck Combo (chicken and sausage) for takeaway. The sausage pizza was just made fresh and smelt really good. Love the garlic knotts..."
Kenny Giovani Watono
"Great pizzas. Open till late. Convenient..."
Sophia Liu
"Good little pizza shop.... Giant pizza 🍕 Chicken with buffalo and blue cheese ranch swirl is a go to for..."
Chris Geldard
Sal's Authentic New York Pizza - Beach Street
Sal's Authentic New York Pizza - Beach Street
87/100 (249 ratings)
Quick Bites
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Fast food
Vegan Options
Pizza
American
Street Food
Italian
American
Fast Food
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Lunch
mozzarella sticks
Half and Half
Meat Lovers Pizza
Garlic Knots
Extra Cheese Pepperoni
Free Range Buffalo Wings
Well Guarded Pizza
Sit down
American
Street Food
Fast food
Pizza
Italian
Delivery
Takeout
Seating
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"We quickly run in to grab something for dinner on our way back from our accommodation. The servers were lovely and were fine to wait while we decided..."
Laura Gostelow
"Quick and easy to order, not everything was available on the day but what we did get was delicious. Loved being able to sit in store and enjoy rather..."
Kristy Tosello
"It was amazing pizza. Really great service. I would 100% recommend going to Sals over Pizza Hut, Winnie bagos, McDonald’s or subway. Very tasty..."
Blockbuster111
"It was a bit chilly inside due to the door not closing completely, but overall, the pizza was good enough, and the staff was quite friendly and..."
Mayank Pandya
"Grabbed a pepperoni slice which was great, flavour was very NY style which I loved however a bit on the oiley side. Only thing is $7 for a slice..."
S L
"We ordered 2 half's but couldn't have one "the 5 Borough's they didn't have the ingredients on a monday afternoon ..$3 for a snall pot if..."
Jacquimc McQueen
"The pizzas were HUGE! Liked them, but adding more sauces gives more..."
Xela Acig
"It's a small pizza place so limits the Atmosphere . Rated it as I see it. Slices are large and not over priced like many things in Queenstown. ..."
John Whitfield
"Crust is crunchy on the outside and soft & fluffy..."
V
"Awesome pizzas. They totally take you to get the same taste of a New York..."
Sebastian Gomez
"Finally got around to visiting Sal's and it was definitely worth the trip. Great food fantastic people and excellent experience...."
William Wisnewski
"Love the concept of selling pizza by the slice and it’s really good should try the pepperoni..."
armaan chenoy
"One of the best new York style pizzas in town. Must try buffalo chicken..."
Aakash Parikh
"The pizza here is consistently SO good, and I could probably live off the garlic knots alone. We all have such an issue with staffing in QT at the..."
Alice Lockhart
"Server's were extremely nice the food was amazing and came out very..."
Hunter Williams